Sisulu faces embarrassing plagiarism claim, but spokesperson says allegations are 'stupid', 'ridiculous'
This article has been supplied.
Plagiarism accusations against Tourism Minister Lindiwe Sisulu were "ridiculous", her spokesperson said on Thursday.
Sisulu's spokesperson, Steven Motale, denied that the tourism minister committed plagiarism, despite penning an opinion piece in which a large section was almost identical to a speech given by former UK attorney-general Dominic Grieve.
Sisulu was responding to criticism around the article she wrote tackling the judiciary. In the article, Sisulu wrote that "mentally colonised" black judges had "settled with the world view and mindset of those who have dispossessed their ancestors". She received backlash from several quarters, including acting Chief Justice Raymond Zondo and African National Congress (ANC) veteran Mavuso Msimang.
The ANC has since distanced itself from Sisulu's comments.
In response to the backlash, Sisulu penned another article published by IOL on Wednesday. In the article, Sisulu said her comments on the judiciary were "narrowly read".
However, the 2 800-word article featured a 400-word section almost identical to a speech given by Grieve in 2013. The similarities between the speech and Sisulu's opinion piece was first picked up by Gareth van Onselen, a political analyst.
The section quotes philosopher Professor Joseph Raz and distinguished UK jurist Lord Tom Bingham.
Motale denied that any plagiarism had taken place. He said anyone accusing the minister of plagiarism was "stupid".
"Plagiarism is when a person, in writing something, uses the words and thoughts of someone else without giving credit to the original author. Minister Sisulu cited the author, the source, the specific piece and date of publication or court ruling instance. This is the exact opposite of plagiarism," he said.
"Whoever makes this charge is either incredibly stupid or incredibly desperate to smear the minister. He or she is a scandal. Go read the 'plagiarism declaration' every university student must sign for every paper they write. This is completely ridiculous."
Sisulu's article makes no reference to Grieve, despite her phrasing bearing a striking resemblance to his thoughts and writing.
Motale said plagiarism was "not acknowledging another person's work or ideas when you use it in your writings, speeches and other scholarly efforts".
However, he said seeing as Sisulu had attributed the content to Bingham and Raz, it could not be considered plagiarism.
"In an opinion piece, as opposed to a dissertation, that is all that is required and possible. The writer is not expected to clutter an op-ed piece with footnotes to the extent these guys seem to imply," he added.
Motale said using ideas that were common knowledge or generally accepted as fact did not require one to cite a source.
"The writings of Lord Bingham on the rule of law are commonly accepted as the textbook definition of the subject. But the minister cited the sources," said Motale.
"The writings of these authors have been reproduced and discussed in various other publications without any substantive changes being made to their key themes on the rule of law."
Article Enquiry
Email Article
Save Article
Feedback
To advertise email advertising@creamermedia.co.za or click here
Announcements
What's On
Subscribe to improve your user experience...
Option 1 (equivalent of R125 a month):
Receive a weekly copy of Creamer Media's Engineering News & Mining Weekly magazine
(print copy for those in South Africa and e-magazine for those outside of South Africa)
Receive daily email newsletters
Access to full search results
Access archive of magazine back copies
Access to Projects in Progress
Access to ONE Research Report of your choice in PDF format
Option 2 (equivalent of R375 a month):
All benefits from Option 1
PLUS
Access to Creamer Media's Research Channel Africa for ALL Research Reports, in PDF format, on various industrial and mining sectors
including Electricity; Water; Energy Transition; Hydrogen; Roads, Rail and Ports; Coal; Gold; Platinum; Battery Metals; etc.
Already a subscriber?
Forgotten your password?
Receive weekly copy of Creamer Media's Engineering News & Mining Weekly magazine (print copy for those in South Africa and e-magazine for those outside of South Africa)
➕
Recieve daily email newsletters
➕
Access to full search results
➕
Access archive of magazine back copies
➕
Access to Projects in Progress
➕
Access to ONE Research Report of your choice in PDF format
RESEARCH CHANNEL AFRICA
R4500 (equivalent of R375 a month)
SUBSCRIBEAll benefits from Option 1
➕
Access to Creamer Media's Research Channel Africa for ALL Research Reports on various industrial and mining sectors, in PDF format, including on:
Electricity
➕
Water
➕
Energy Transition
➕
Hydrogen
➕
Roads, Rail and Ports
➕
Coal
➕
Gold
➕
Platinum
➕
Battery Metals
➕
etc.
Receive all benefits from Option 1 or Option 2 delivered to numerous people at your company
➕
Multiple User names and Passwords for simultaneous log-ins
➕
Intranet integration access to all in your organisation

















