Shell can proceed with seismic survey after environmental groups lose urgent court bid

Shell logo

Photo by Bloomberg

3rd December 2021

By: News24Wire


Font size: - +

The high court has dismissed an urgent application to block Shell from proceeding with a seismic survey off the Eastern Cape coast.

The ruling was delivered by Judge Avinash Govindjee at the Eastern Cape Division of the Makhanda High Court on Wednesday.

Earlier this week, four environmental and human rights organisations - Greenpeace Africa, Natural Justice, the Border Deep Sea Angling Association and the Kei Mouth Ski Boat Club - filed an urgent application to block the seismic survey, given the alleged harm it would case to the environment and marine life.

The applicants wanted the seismic survey - which will take place off the coast between Morgans Bay and Port St Johns - to be halted until a judicial review of Shell's environmental authorisation is complete.

Shell and the Department of Mineral Resources and Energy, respondents in the matter - both argued that the applicants failed to demonstrate urgency. Shell's legal counsel Adrian Friedman even suggested that the urgency was "self-created" by the applicants by only filing their court papers this week, days before the seismic survey was due to start.

In his ruling, Govindjee said that he was satisfied that there was no "undue delay" in bringing the application - as the applicants were only made aware of it on 29 October 2021.

The applicants had also challenged the public participation process - claiming that not all interested and affected parties were notified about the exploration right granted to Shell, nor of the two subsequent renewals that followed.

Shell on the other hand filed supplementary affidavits on Thursday indicating that "hundreds" of interested and affected parties were notified, including the applicants - Border Deep Angling Association and the Kei Mouth Ski Boat Club.

Environmental harm

In his ruling, Govindjee said that Shell has provided details on compliance with its Environmental Management Programme and the mitigation measures that would be in place for the survey. 

"Given the paucity of information as to the likelihood of environmental harm, the balance of convenience favours Shell," he said.

The applicants "failed" to convince the judge that there is a "well rounded apprehension of irreparable harm" if the interim relief or interdict is not granted.

"Upon consideration of the affidavits as a whole according to facts and probabilities, the outcomes are the same and I must exercise discretion to reject the application," Govindjee said.

"The question is whether the seismic survey to be undertaken should be interdicted ending final determination of a separate review application. That question has been answered [in the] negative."

The application was dismissed with costs.

Meanwhile, on Thursday Wild Coast communities lodged an application to urgent interdict Shell's exploration, also pending a judicial review of Shell's environmental authorisation. The communities are represented by the Legal Resources Centre and Richard Spoor Attorneys and are joined by two civil society organisations that work in the area - Sustaining the Wild Coast and All Rise Attorneys for Climate and the Environment.

"Small-scale fishers from the Amadiba, Cwebe, Hobeni, Port Saint Johns and Kei Mouth communities say that Shell is not entitled to commence the surveys without getting an environmental authorisation in terms of the National Environmental Management Act (NEMA)," a statement from the Legal Resources Centre read. According to these applicants, Shell's Environmental Management Programme (EMPr) which was approved under the Minerals and Petroleum Resources Development Act (MPRDA) is "plainly insufficient".

The applicants also indicated that they only learnt of Shell's planned seismic survey in the last three weeks, as petitions and information started circulating on social media. According to the Legal Resources Centre, Shell consulted stakeholders in the commercial and recreational fishing sectors, but ignored small-scale fishing communities.

Edited by News24Wire



Weir Minerals Africa and Middle East
Weir Minerals Africa and Middle East

Weir Minerals Europe, Middle East and Africa is a global supplier of excellent minerals solutions, including pumps, valves, hydrocyclones,...

Booyco Electronics
Booyco Electronics

Booyco Electronics, South African pioneer of Proximity Detection Systems, offers safety solutions for underground and surface mining, quarrying,...


Latest Multimedia

sponsored by

Magazine round up | 24 May 2024
Magazine round up | 24 May 2024
24th May 2024

Option 1 (equivalent of R125 a month):

Receive a weekly copy of Creamer Media's Engineering News & Mining Weekly magazine
(print copy for those in South Africa and e-magazine for those outside of South Africa)
Receive daily email newsletters
Access to full search results
Access archive of magazine back copies
Access to Projects in Progress
Access to ONE Research Report of your choice in PDF format

Option 2 (equivalent of R375 a month):

All benefits from Option 1
Access to Creamer Media's Research Channel Africa for ALL Research Reports, in PDF format, on various industrial and mining sectors including Electricity; Water; Energy Transition; Hydrogen; Roads, Rail and Ports; Coal; Gold; Platinum; Battery Metals; etc.

Already a subscriber?

Forgotten your password?







sq:0.5 0.559s - 169pq - 6rq
Subscribe Now