R/€ = 15.26
R/$ = 14.41
Au 1057.95 $/oz
Pt 835.50 $/oz
Jun 25, 2008
SA’s bank charges too high, inquiry findsBack
© Reuse this South Africa’s bank charges were higher than what they would be at competitive levels, the Competition Commission said on Wednesday, following the completion of an inquiry into the level and structure of bank charges and access to the retail banking sector.
The banking enquiry panel, which was established in August 2006, has found that the current market structure, because of current information asymmetries and product complexities, meant that South African banks had the ability to abuse their market power.
The commission said in a statement that the information gathered by the enquiry had painted a “complex and sophisticated” banking system involving the four big banks, which controlled over 90% of the retail market for personal transactions.
It stated that, in 2006, transactional fee income had represented one-third of banks’ total income, or R34,5-billion. The enquiry’s remit did not include interest charges or corporate and business banking.
The panel made 28 recommendations aimed at addressing concerns raised by consumers, small and prospective banks and nonbank stakeholders.
The first area of concern related to the high penalty fees charged for rejected debit orders. The enquiry has found that these fees – sometimes as high as R110 a transaction – were too high and that they contributed to the “vicious cycle” of consumer indebtedness.
“Penalty fees on rejected debit orders contribute significantly to the earnings of the banks and are much higher than the cost associated with processing the transaction. Additionally, customers are penalised for rejected debit orders by the service provider with whom they have a contract,” it said.
The enquiry believed that banks do not have to further penalise their customers and recommended a cap of R5,00 per rejected debit order. This should be “more than adequate” to cover processing costs.
A second recommendation was that banks adopt a system which would make it easier for customers to cancel debit order instructions directy at their bank.
Five of the 28 recommendations addressed the current ATM pricing model, which was applied to transactions where a customer of one bank used the ATM of another bank.
The enquiry found that the way in which banks set the carriage fee – payable between banks when a customer uses the ATM of another bank – was problematic under the Competition Act. The report advocated the implementation of a direct-charging model, offering full disclosure and transparency at the start of the transaction, in order to allow for more price competition in the provision of ATM services.
The report also stated that opening access for nonbanks to the national payment system and developing an appropriate regulatory scheme would increase competition in the provision of banking services.
“The current system makes it difficult for potentially innovative competitors to enter the market,” it stated, adding that it recommended amending the National Payment System Act and broadening the regulatory regime to open the market to suitably qualified participants.
The panel said it was presented with concerns around the existence and level of current interbank arrangements and the costs associated with branded payment cards (Visa or MasterCard). It has found that, while some payment streams might well require interchange, the method by which interbank fees were set – at the maximum level merchants were willing to bear – was where the potential abuse was.
“This abuse contributes to rising shop prices across the board, unfairly punishing lower-income customers paying with cash,” it stated.
The enquiry recommended that interbank fee setting be subject to an independent, objective and transparent regulatory process and that certain rules established by MasterCard and Visa be abolished.
Nine recommendations addressed the difficulty consumers face while making product and price comparisons. Bundling, packaging and pricing make choice difficult and weaken price competition. The panel found that the complexity of products and prices, inadequate transparency and disclosure and the costs associated with switching – combined with the reluctance of banks to price compete – created customer inertia that enforced the banks’ market power.
Recommendations to counteract their market power included amending the Banking Association’s Code of Banking Practice to develop a minimum set of standards for disclosure of product and price information, standardisation of terminology as well as a Switching Code. Other recommendations, such as a banking fee calculator and marketing generic customer profiles were aimed at improving comparability. Setting up a central FICA repository was also recommended.
“This concludes the work of the enquiry panel, for which we are grateful,” said Competition Commissioner Shan Ramburuth.
“The banking sector is ripe for innovation on the back of new business processes and technologies. Already we are seeing responses consistent with the direction of this report, which can fuel this dynamism. We look forward to the continued co-operation of the banks to find solutions to these complex matters.”
Once the full, 600-page report was released, the Competition Commission in consultation with the Department of Trade and Industry and National Treasury would map a way forward.
The enquiry was held from August 2006 to June 2008. During these 22 months, the panel and the technical team held 21 days of public hearings in three cities and conducted 101 stakeholder meetings.
The views of a range of interested parties including banks, consumer groups, small and prospective banks, non-banks and regulators were canvassed during this process.
Edited by: Mariaan Webb© Reuse this Comment Guidelines (150 word limit)
Creamer Media Senior Researcher and Deputy Editor Online
Recent Research Reports
Water 2015: A review of South Africa's water sector (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s Water 2015 Report considers the aforementioned issues, not only in the South African context but also in the African and global context in terms of supply and demand, water stress and insecurity, and access to water and sanitation, besides others.
Input Sector Review: Pumps 2015 (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s 2015 Input Sector Review on Pumps provides an overview of South Africa’s pumps industry with particular focus on pump manufacture and supply, aftermarket services, marketing strategies, local and export demand, imports, sector support, investment...
Liquid Fuels 2015: A review of South Africa's liquid fuels sector (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s Liquid Fuels 2015 Report examines these issues in the context of South Africa’s business environment; oil and gas exploration; fuel pricing; the development of the country’s biofuels industry; the logistics of transporting liquid fuels; and...
Road and Rail 2015: A review of South Africa's road and rail sectors (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s Road and Rail 2015 report examines South Africa’s road and rail transport system, with particular focus on the size and state of the country’s road and rail infrastructure and network, the funding and maintenance of these respective networks, and...
Defence 2015: A review of South Africa's defence sector (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s Coal 2015 report examines South Africa’s coal industry with regards to the business environment, the key participants in the sector, local demand, export sales and coal logistics, projects being undertaken by the large and smaller participants in the...
Real Economy Year Book 2015 (PDF Report)
There are very few beacons of hope on South Africa’s economic horizon. Economic growth is weak, unemployment is rising, electricity supply is insufficient to meet demand and/or spur growth, with poor prospects for many of the commodities mined and exported. However,...
This Week's Magazine
The BMW Group will invest R6-billion at BMW Group South Africa’s (BMW SA’s) Rosslyn plant to produce the next-generation X3 sports-activity vehicle (SAV) for the local and export markets. Rosslyn will continue production of the current 3 Series through its lifecycle,...
The lack of consequences for poor performance and transgressions on the part of contractors remains a significant hurdle to tackling South Africa’s service delivery challenges, delegates heard at the Consulting Engineers South Africa Infrastructure Indaba, on...
City of Ekurhuleni executive mayor Mondli Gungubele earlier this month officially named the city’s bus rapid transit (BRT) system, Harambee.
About 58% of unstructured data stored by companies is dark data, which means that the value or regulatory importance of the data has not been determined. Subsequently, most of the stored data add costs, rather than increasing revenue or reduce regulatory risks, says...
Effective logistics, import/export and manufacturing consulting services require detailed industry knowledge and experience, but can add significant value to these industries by providing expert advice on various technical elements in their value chains, says...