Icasa won’t oppose Vodacom ruling, independence questioned
© Reuse this
Communications regulator the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (Icasa) on Monday said it would not oppose the judgement handed down by the High Court on Sunday, regarding the Vodacom and Vodafone merger.
Sunday’s judgement meant that the Congress of Trade Unions (Cosatu) and Icasa did not get the interdict they sought, and this signalled the go-ahead for mobile operator Vodacom to list on the JSE and restructure, so that UK-based Vodafone holds a majority 65% interest in the company.
The remaining 35%, which was held by Telkom, was unbundled and the company listed on the JSE on Monday.
The regulator “has heard of the judgment”, and although it did not have a copy of the actual judgement in its possession, would not be opposing it. “There wont be any follow up from our side,” said Icasa spokesperson Sekgoela Sekgoela.
On the other hand, Cosatu national spokesperson Patrick Craven on Monday said that “the fight against this deal will continue. Cosatu will be consulting with its lawyers on possible further court action to appeal against the decision, up to the Constitutional Court if necessary.”
“Vodacom group received a letter from Icasa on Friday, May 15, 2009 purporting to rescind its previous decision that the transactions only required notification rather than prior approval from Icasa, and stating that a public consultation process will take place. Vodacom Group continues to believe that only a notification of the transactions to Icasa was required,” said the newly listed Vodacom, in a statement to shareholders on Monday.
Sekgoela confirmed that the envisaged public consultation process would no longer take place.
Icasa initially said that the merger could go ahead without regulator approval.
On Friday, Icasa rescinded the decision after pressure from the Communication Workers Union (CWU), and more recently the Cosatu, which filed court papers requesting the Icasa decision to be set aside.
ICASA INDEPENDENCE QUESTIONED
For Icasa to intervene at this late stage and rescind the initial decision that it took, proves one of two things, explained Africa Analysis telecoms analyst Dabek Pater.
“Either that Icasa staff is incompetent because there was a period of two or three months when the transaction was announced publicly, and they should have been able to investigate it to a sufficient degree, to decide whether they did need to engage in a more open, public transparent process or not. Or otherwise, it would mean that someone has been intervening behind the scenes, suggesting strongly to Icasa that they should step in and support the Cosatu application,” Pater said.
“None of the cases are favourable to Icasa’s image,” he added.
Pater suggested that Icasa does have enough competent staff and resources to dedicate time and effort to a transaction of this size.
Indeed, it was the largest transaction in the South African telecoms market to date.
This posed the question why Icasa chose, so late, to intervene?
“If there is some third party involvement, resulting in Icasa voicing reservations, then that would, unfortunately, mean that it is not as independent as we would like it to be. This is problematic, because the reason we have these institutions is to provide checks and balances to maintain the democratic system,” Pater said in an interview with Engineering News Online.
The initial signal sent to the international investment community was not positive.
“For something like this to happen at the last minute before the listing, and the conclusion of the deal, it presents doubt in the mind of the investors as to the surety of our system, and an assurance that things will go as promised,” noted Pater.
He did add, however, that the High Court decision not to issue the interdict, sent a countering positive message, “reassuring the world that our legal system is still reliable, and sufficiently strong to act independently”.
The need to attract foreign investment into South Africa was emphasised, particularly in the current economic climate. “We cant afford to scare off potential foreign investors by having a political force such as Cosatu bringing the whole process to a grinding halt,” stressed Pater.
It was, however, felt that the debacle did not damage the Vodacom listing. Investors hoping to acquire shares were confident that the listing would go ahead as planned.
“But, had it gone the other way, I think it would have done quite a bit of damage. The positive growth in the share price shows confidence in the company – despite the wobble along the way,” said Pater.
The Vodacom merger with Vodafone was approved by the Competition Tribunal in February 2009, despite the CWU raising concerns that ranged from Vodafone’s alleged “bad record” and “union-bashing” tactics, to the potential decrease in Telkom revenue after the sale of its stake in Vodacom, which would lead to retrenchments at Telkom.
At the end of April, the CWU’s bid to halt Telkom's sale of its 15% stake in Vodacom was dismissed with costs in the High Court in Pretoria.
On May 8, Cosatu applied to the High Court in Pretoria to halt the deal between Telkom and Vodafone, stating that without Icasa approval the transaction was void, and Icasa was entitled to void Vodacom’s license.
When questioned on the issue of Vodacom’s operating license being withdrawn, Sekgoela said, “no, lets not even start speculate about that.”
Cosatu was opposed to the deal stating that it would result in job losses, and loss of revenue at Telkom, which would lose the significant contribution to the bottom line from Vodacom.
Cosatu also said that the entity was a “strategic national asset”, which should not be controlled by a foreign company.
Pater pointed out that there was no factual evidence that any job losses would take place.
Edited by: Mariaan Webb
© Reuse this
Comment Guidelines (150 word limit)
Other Telecoms News
Metadata is a powerful and efficient tool to organise unstructured data on-site or in the cloud and understand what actions must be taken
Controlling unstructured data using metadata and a data management system improves the management and use of unstructured data in companies, while also reducing risks, says data management specialist company Soarsoft International director Chris Hathaway. Metadata...
The Quasar 4k cameras are more affordable to install, maintain and more bandwidth efficient than HD cameras
The ultra-high-definition camera, supplied by Graphic Image Technologies (GIT), provides better and higher-resolution coverage of areas than high-definition (HD) cameras and one camera can also replace two or three HD cameras, reducing costs, says GIT executive...
Telecoms giant Vodafone has so far not held talks with South Africa over the London-listed firm buying Pretoria's stake in its local subsidiary Vodacom, CE Vittorio Colao said on Wednesday. However, Colao told a news conference in Johannesburg he was open to talks...
Article contains comments
The government of St Helena (SHG) and its Department for International Development (DFID) on Friday appointed airline Comair as the provider of air services to St Helena with the Island’s first airport opening in 2016. Comair would offer a weekly Saturday service,...
The Department of Communications (DoC) digital terrestrial television (DTT) project team was accelerating its efforts to “revive” South Africa’s long anticipated transition from analogue to digital broadcasting. After a more than six-year delay, the next few weeks...
Residential property prices are forecast to grow at 7.2% this year, on the back of 6.72% growth in 2014.
Recent Research Reports
Projects in Progress 2015 - First Edition (PDF Report)
In fact, this edition of Creamer Media’s Projects in Progress 2015 supplement tracks developments taking place under the Renewable Energy Independent Power Producer Procurement Programme, which has had four bidding rounds. It appears to remain a shining light on the...
Electricity 2015: A review of South Africa's electricity sector (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s Electricity 2015 report provides an overview of State-owned power utility Eskom and independent power producers, as well as electricity planning, transmission, distribution and the theft thereof, besides other issues.
Construction 2015: A review of South Africa’s construction sector (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s Construction 2015 Report examines South Africa’s construction industry over the past 12 months. The report provides insight into the business environment; the key participants in the sector; local construction demand; geographic diversification;...
Liquid Fuels 2014 - A review of South Africa's Liquid Fuels sector (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s Liquid Fuels 2014 Report examines these issues, focusing on the business environment, oil and gas exploration, the country’s feedstock supplies, the development of South Africa’s biofuels industry, fuel pricing, competition in the sector, the...
Water 2014: A review of South Africa's water sector (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s Water 2014 report considers the aforementioned issues, not only in the South African context, but also in the African and global context, and examines the issues of water and sanitation, water quality and the demand for water, among others.
Defence 2014: A review of South Africa's defence industry (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s Defence 2014 report examines South Africa’s defence industry, with particular focus on the key participants in the sector, the innovations that have come out of the sector, local and export demand, South Africa’s controversial multibillion-rand...
This Week's Magazine
Projected capital expenditure (capex) in the South African automotive assembly industry should reach a record R7.48-billion this year, says the National Association of Automobile Manufacturers of South Africa (Naamsa) in its 2014 fourth quarter business review. Capex...
After several years of navigating project-threatening red tape and currency fluctuations, the 4.4 MW Bronkhorstspruit biogas power plant, which will supply clean energy to a leading automotive manufacturer in Gauteng, is expected to enter production before June....
The raw material for the pilot plant would be supplied from the dissolving wood pulp plants at Sappi’s Saiccor and Ngodwana mills, in South Africa, and the Cloquet mill, in the US
South African paper and pulp producer Sappi reported earlier this month that it would build a pilot plant for the production of low-cost Cellulose NanoFibrils, or CNF (nanocellulose) at the Brightlands Chemelot Campus in Sittard-Geleen in the Netherlands.
The long-term outlook for Nigeria is a country that has the potential to be very strong. So affirmed International Monetary Fund (IMF) Nigeria Mission Chief and Senior Resident Representative Dr Gene Leon on recently. "But we are starting from a point of huge...
Poor infrastructure planning and inadequate maintenance are becoming increasingly problematic for new developments and the associated infrastructure required to support such developments.
In many urban and rural municipalities, the state of infrastructure has been...