Mar 16, 2012
Economic case for lifting shale ban explored, but opposition remainsBack
Karoo Action Group|Mineral Resources|Shell|Water Defense|South Africa|United States|USD|Coal Mining|Constant Natural Gas Price|Electricity|Energy|Energy Equivalent|Energy Security|Gas Turbines|Shale Gas|Shale Gas Development|Shale-gas Resources|Yearly Gross Domestic Product|Bonang Mohale|Jonathan Deal|Susan Shabangu|Tony Twine|Fracturing
© Reuse this
Speaking at the release of an economic modelling exercise completed by Econometrix, but bankrolled by hydraulic fracturing (fracking) proponent Shell, Tony Twine said fracking could add between R80-billion and R200-billion to the country’s yearly gross domestic product (GDP) if only a small portion of the speculated shale resource base was exploited.
The figures were based on the exploitation of either 20 tcf over 25 years, or 50 tcf over the same period, at a constant natural gas price of $8/mcf (thousand cubic feet), which was higher than the prevailing price of around $5/mcf.
The figures selected for the two scenarios equated to 4% and 10% respectively of the estimated resource size, which was currently estimated by the US Energy Information Agency as being 485 tcf, or the fifth-largest globally.
Twine said that between 300 000 and 700 000 upstream and downstream jobs could be generated from what would be an entirely new industry, which could account for between 3.3% and 9.6% respectively of total GDP in 2010 terms – larger than the contribution from coal mining in the year, which stood at 1.8%.
Energy security was another key theme explored, with the study noting that, converted to oil equivalent, the estimated resource base would have the energy equivalent of 400 years of South Africa’s fuel consumption of around 500 000 bbl/d.
“This is indeed a large resource. The problem is that we’re not sure that it’s there,” Twine said.
In the context of expected energy growth in South Africa, shale gas development could be a ‘game changer’, as the exploitation of a 24 tcf resource could power about 20 GW of combined-cycle gas turbines, generating about 130 000 GWh of electricity a year – more than half the country’s current production.
But to firm up the real potential of shale gas, exploration was required, as the “macro- economic modelling indicates very firmly to us that we need to think twice about simply dismissing the potential of the Karoo gas as not being worth the risk on ecological grounds, on social grounds, on technological grounds on legal grounds”.
Twine stressed that it was not in his competence to speak definitively on the ecological issues being raised in the public debate. But he argued that, besides the macroeconomic tailwinds, the internal rates of return associated with possible fracking operations were suffi- ciently large to ensure that developers paid attention to mitigating all the key risk factors, particularly the environmental risks.
Shell country chairperson Bonang Mohale said the group remained keen to move ahead with exploration and spend up to $200-million in a prospecting campaign that would involve the drilling of up to 24 wells in a 90 000 km2 area.
He said that this commitment remained despite the uncertainty surrounding fracking in South Africa and the fact that the moratorium had endured for more than 12 months.
Shell was expecting further clarity once Cabinet had applied its mind to a task team report in either March or April. The decision might also be held back until after the Square Kilometre Array sighting announcement, which was expected in early April.
The Econometrix report follows on a national polling research report, also commissioned by Shell, to test the views of South Africans on the possible exploration of gas in the Karoo. Ipsos Markinor released findings indicating that the majority of the 2 000 respondents were in favour of determining the presence of gas in the Karoo, but that they would like job creation, economic development and environmental issues to be addressed.
Mohale would not be drawn on what Shell had spent on the reports, but said the company would “be prepared to spend whatever it takes to educate . . . to shed more light” on this subject.
But the opposition to fracking was also well organised, with the Treasure the Karoo Action Group (TKAG) having recently also formalised relations with US antifracking group Water Defense.
It had also made legal progress in action taken against Mineral Resources Minister Susan Shabangu, who filed an answering affidavit in a matter brought by the TKAG, which was seeking to have the identities of the members of the government fracking advisory task team disclosed.
It also dismissed the results of the Ipsos Markinor opinion survey, commissioned by Shell, saying that opinion polls fail to factually address the issues being considered by government and should be irrelevant to any outcome of the task team’s “fact-based” investigation.
In response to questions posed by Engi- neering News regarding the Econometrix report, TKAG chairperson Jonathan Deal questioned the validity of the report’s description of the upstream and downstream jobs as ‘permanent’ and ‘sustainable’ on the basis that no aspect of the fossil-fuel industry could be so described.
He added that the Econometrix report appeared to ‘cherry-pick’ data and reports from elsewhere. “We wonder if the author has considered data available from the US, in which actual industry studies reflect that shale gas wells fall to subeconomic levels in an average period of 36 to 48 months, and that, on average, they operate at approximately 20% of the first-day yield after 12 months.”
Deal said there was still a lack of scientific and economic consensus on fracking globally and that, “until this debate is more settled”, particularly in the US, the Econometrix “projections could be viewed only as an opinion”.
“There is, undeniably, a requirement for a thorough cost-benefit analysis of shale gas mining in South Africa,” he added, but said TKAG had grave reservations on the depth and scope of the Shell-sponsored study.
An independent study, framed within a strategic environmental assessment, would encompass aspects that must be settled before taking a decision as to whether or not shale-gas mining is the best and only way for South Africa to sustainably address its energy, employment and revenue needs.
Edited by: Martin Zhuwakinyu© Reuse this Comment Guidelines
Other News This Week News
Recent Research Reports
Steel 2014: A review of South Africa's steel sector (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s Steel 2014 report provides an overview of the global steel industry and particularly of South Africa’s steel sector over the past year, including details of production and consumption, as well as the country's primary carbon steel and stainless...
Projects in Progress 2014 - First Edition (PDF Report)
This publication contains insight into progress at the delayed Medupi and Kusile coal-fired projects, in Mpumalanga and Limpopo respectively, as well as at the Ingula pumped-storage scheme, which is under construction on the border between the Free State and...
Automotive 2014: A review of South Africa's automotive sector (PDF Report)
The report provides insight into the business environment, the key participants in the sector, local construction demand, geographic diversification, competition within the sector, corporate activity, skills, safety, environmental considerations and the challenges...
Construction 2014: A review of South Africa's construction sector (PDF Report)
Construction data released during 2013 hints at a halt to the decline in the industry during the last few years, with some commentators averring that the industry could be poised for recovery. However, others have urged caution, noting that the prospects for a...
Electricity 2014: A Review of South Africa's Electricity Sector (PDF Report)
This report provides an overview of the state of electricity generation and transmission in South Africa and examines electricity planning, investment in generation capacity, electricity tariffs, the role of independent power producers and demand-focused initiatives,...
Defence 2013: A review of South Africa's defence industry (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s 2013 Defence Report examines South Africa’s defence industry, with particular focus on the key players in the sector, the innovations that have come out of the defence sector, local and export demand, South Africa’s controversial...
This Week's Magazine
The Electronic Systems Laboratory (ESL) of the Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering at Stellenbosch University is strongly reaffirming its position as one of South Africa’s leading centres for satellite technology and expertise. It is currently...
The world’s lowest-cost diesel-electric locomotive is not made in China, but in Pretoria, at RRL Grindrod Locomotives’ newly upgraded 30 000 m2 plant. The company’s locomotive pricing is “more competitive than any other original-equipment manufacturer (OEM)...
The South African Defence Review 2012, released to the public at the end of last month (despite the year given in its title) recommends the creation of the post of Chief Defence Scientist. This official would be responsible for the management of defence technology...
AltX-listed engineering technology company Ansys has been awarded an R188-million contract by Transnet to supply integrated dashboard display systems to the freight rail utility’s locomotives. Black-owned and controlled Ansys developed the bespoke integrated system...
South Africa’s sole nuclear power station Koeberg, which is located in the Western Cape, breached a major operations milestone on April 4, which marked the thirtieth anniversary of Unit 1 having been connected to the grid. Eskom, which operates the two-unit plant,...