Aug 15, 2012
Constitutional Court asked to set aside Gauteng e-toll interdictBack
South African National Roads Agency Limited|South Africa|Constitutional Court|E-tolling|Energy|Transport|Bill Prinsloo
© Reuse this
Attorneys representing the parties reiterated that the interdict, brought against Sanral by the Opposition to Urban Tolling Alliance (Outa) and handed down by North Gauteng High Court Judge Bill Prinsloo in April, placed pressure on Sanral's ability to meet the debts incurred during the upgrading of Gauteng's highway and caused irreparable harm to the company.
Outa sought an interdict while challenging Sanral's funding model, in efforts to resolve issues surrounding the way in which the agency would collect the toll fees on the highways making up the Gauteng Freeway Improvement Project (GFIP) and the costs related to the collection, before the system went live.
The National Treasury and Sanral stated that it was unrealistic to halt what was ready to generate revenue pending reviews and that the judge should have run scenarios outlining the harm that could actually be done to the opposing parties should the tolling start, as well as the damage Sanral could face if the tolling was halted.
In its appeal documents to the court, the National Treasury requested the court to determine whether the High Court applied the correct test in granting the interdict, as it believed that it was inconsistent with the separation of powers. Sanral believed that the court should have placed all its energy into pushing the review and declined the interdict.
The agency also reported that the suspension of the tolling of the upgraded highways also resulted in a Moody's downgrading of the agency, reputational harm for South Africa and obliged the government to relocate resources and revise public finances, leading government to reduce expenditure in other areas to offset the revenue loss.
However, Outa believed that, while there were consequences such as lost revenue and the possibility of the National Treasury having to find the funds to maintain Sanral's debt, the interim interdict was not causing the agency irrepairable harm or even more harm than any other standard interdicts ordered in other cases.
Outa stated that the interim order was not the reason for Sanral's harm, but that it was a number of external factors, including a lack of readiness to implement tolling seamlessly and requirements for amendments of related legislation, besides others.
Responding to questions by deputy chief justice Dikgang Moseneke surrounding Sanral's delayed implementation on four previous occasions, its legal team argued that, despite costing about R2.7-billion, the bulk of the suspensions were to ensure sufficient public participation and once owing to technical difficulties.
But Sanral's representative stated that, while the system may hold some imperfections, it was ready to go and could be generating revenue in the interim, particularly as the legal matters were not expected to be concluded before the end of 2012 and into late 2013.
Further, defending its stance on the user-pay model, Sanral noted that the implementation of a fuel levy or other alternative means of tax was inefficient as the funds meant for the maintenance of roads would compete with government's other social and economic expenditure responsibilities.
The agency noted that the implementation if a higher fuel levy, for example, would burden the country's economy, would raise transport costs, result in shifts in consumption and production choices, penalise those with less efficient vehicles and affect those in other regions that would not benefit from the use of the upgraded highways.
It was also stated that 94% of the e-tolling revenue was expected to be sourced from the 'top quintile of Gauteng income earners' and that a month-long dry run in June found that 91% of the users would pay less than R200 a month. Less than 0.2% may reach the R550 limit.
Sanral predicted a compliance rate of 93% and a recovery rate of 40% from noncompliant users, adding that it was addressing the manner on which 'deviants' would be dealt with to avoid the clogging of courts through enforcement. However, Sanral was confident that, generally, ordinary citizens would abide by the law.
The toll collections were estimated to cost about 25% of the overall cost of the project over a period of 25 years.
In its appeal affidavits, Sanral outlined that the GFIP would cost R71.4-billion over a 24-year period. This cost encompassed R20.6-billion for the repayment of initial capital costs, R10.6-billion for road maintenance, R6.2-billion for violation processing centre capital and operating expenditure, R12.2-billion for toll-related capital and operating expenses, R1.7-billion for other operational expenses such as freeway lighting and R20-billion for interest during the 24 years.
However, there was no way to determine whether this was unreasonable when compared with general economic improvements and social benefits, including skills and jobs.
The agency stressed that the opposition should have challenged the e-tolling approach while the project was still in its infancy, as the funding mechanism was an integral part of a project and delays in implementation when the project was complete were costly.
A Constitutional Court decision would follow.
Edited by: Mariaan Webb© Reuse this Comment Guidelines
Recent Research Reports
Defence 2013: A review of South Africa's defence industry (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s 2013 Defence Report examines South Africa’s defence industry, with particular focus on the key players in the sector, the innovations that have come out of the defence sector, local and export demand, South Africa’s controversial...
Road and Rail 2013: A review of South Africa's road and rail infrastructure (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s Road and Rail 2013 Report examines South Africa’s road and rail transport system, with particular focus on the size and state of the country’s road and rail network, the funding and maintenance of these respective networks, and the push to move...
Liquid Fuels 2013 (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s 2013 Liquid Fuels report examines South Africa’s liquid fuels market, focusing on the business environment, oil and gas exploration, the country’s feedstock supplies, the development of South Africa’s biofuels industry, fuel pricing,...
Projects in Progress - Second Edition (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s second Projects in Progress supplement considers some of the major project developments under way, including high-profile energy and transport projects, as well as a few of the lower-profile public and private developments. What remains apparent is...
Water 2013: A review of South Africa’s water sector (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s Water 2013 report considers the aforementioned issues, not only in the South African context, but also in the African and global context, and examines the issues of water and sanitation, water quality and the demand for water, among others.
Canadian Mining Roundup for June 2013 (PDF Report)
The June 2013 roundup includes details of the development of TSX-V-listed Aldridge Minerals’ flagship Yenipazar polymetallic project, in Turkey; the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission’s renewal of Cameco’s uranium mining licence pertaining to the Cigar Lake...
This Week's Magazine
Mitsubishi Motors South Africa (MMSA) has introduced a 4x2 derivative of its Pajero Sport sports-utility vehicle (SUV), which will give it access to a substantial slice of the full-size SUV market, where it will compete with the likes of the Ford Everest, Chevrolet...
South African Energy Minister Ben Martins has affirmed that the government wants the country to be globally competitive in the nuclear sector. "Our responsibility has always been ... to ensure that, in nuclear energy, South Africa can compete with the rest of the...
Mercedes-Benz South Africa (MBSA) president and CEO Dr Martin Zimmermann describes the new S-Class as “a special place to be”, with the car creating a sense of “wellness” once you are seated inside the German brand’s flagship model. It is difficult to argue...
Water scarcity and water-quality issues are broadly recognised and understood in most political, business and civil organisations in South Africa, but solving water issues will require wide and continuous action in catchments and municipalities by organisations and...
Work is well under way on the R212-million Imvutshane dam, 30 km north-west of Stanger, in KwaZulu-Natal, which is a key link in supplying people in rural Maphumulo with a reliable source of safe drinking water.