Nov 19, 2010
Capitalism is different from free market libertarianismBack
© Reuse this
One of the justifications for the liberalisation of capital movements by government is that this will help weaken the rand. I think this is a weak and disingenuous argument used opportunistically to promote an ideological view about the freedom of people to move their money about the world as they wish. The important question that we in South Africa have to ask ourselves is whether this ideological stance is appropriate in a country where there is a huge level of inequality in income and wealth. This inequality has its roots in colonial and apartheid dispossession, oppression and exploitation. The inequality in South Africa still has a strong racial dimension. One of the compromises that ended apartheid was that the economy and the distribution of wealth would be left largely unchanged. There have been attempts to lessen inequality in South Africa, including black economic empowerment and land redistribution, but these have been piecemeal and relatively ineffective. As a result, inequality has worsened and we are nowhere near dealing with massive unemployment and poverty in our society.
Many people wish to forget South Africa’s past. They ask when we are going to stop looking back and get on with building the future. However, we cannot move forward without understanding the impact of the past. Our politi- cal, legal, economic and cultural institutions cannot be built overnight – they are built over centu- ries and, often, change very slowly. In most historical epochs, building wealth takes generations. Colo- nialism and apartheid destroyed the lives and wealth of indigenous South Africans in order to build the fortunes of the Dutch East India Company, European and US investors and a relatively small settler population. We have to acknowledge that history.
Many people say that we have to accept the way capitalism works – some people are rich and others are poor. They say the rich will not invest if they are told what to do with their money. They say that a capitalist system has to be based on incentives, not rules and regulations. I disagree. We have seen capitalism work very differently in different countries. We have seen capitalism work very differently in the same countries during different periods. The people who say that we just have to accept that capitalism is the same as a free market system are ignorant of the history and geographical variety of capitalism. It is possible to have highly regulated systems of capitalism, where the State directs the allocation of capital and tightly controls the movement of capital across borders. Capitalism does not require free markets. We should not mix up free market libertarianism with capitalism. In fact, the fastest economic growth and economic development and the lowest levels of inequality occurred where there was tight regulation, particularly of financial institutions and capital flows.
The strong global moves to promote environmental sustain- ability and the rules and regula- tions to stop businesses from harming the environment are clear indications that we cannot allow free market libertarianism. The laws controlling drugs, weapons and protecting human rights are further indicators that capitalism should not allow people to do anything they please with their wealth.
Today, we realise that finance and the free movement of capital around the world can wreak huge destruction. We have to curtail finance and capital movements not only to promote South Africa’s developmental goals, but also to promote stability and sustainable economic growth. These problems are not unique to South Africa. Most countries now face questions about control over private wealth. The US is faced with growing inequality, unemployment, crumb- ling public infrastructure and a huge government deficit. At the same time, there is huge tax evasion and illicit flows of capital out of the US. They have to introduce regulation against these capital movements. After the financial crisis, many countries are moving to regulate finance, control capital movements and manage their exchange rates. The South African government’s decision to liberalise exchange controls is going against the flow in international economic policy and is an outdated policy. It reflects a certain libertarian ideology and the power of South African finance, and not the developmental goals of the country.
Edited by: Martin Zhuwakinyu© Reuse this Comment Guidelines (150 word limit)
Creamer Media Senior Deputy Editor
Other Seeraj Mohamed News
The Corporate Strategy and Industrial Development Research Programme (CSID) - the University of the Witwatersrand's (Wits') economics policy research unit of which I am director – hosted a launch of the Department of Trade and Industry’s (DTI's) capacity building...
We enter 2011 with much global economic uncertainty. South Africans should consider the country's economic policies and activities within the context of an uncertain and volatile global economy.
Recent Research Reports
Steel 2015: A review of South Africa's steel sector (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s Steel 2015 report provides an overview of the key developments in the global steel industry and particularly of South Africa’s steel sector over the past year, including details of production and consumption, as well as the country's primary carbon...
Projects in Progress 2015 - First Edition (PDF Report)
In fact, this edition of Creamer Media’s Projects in Progress 2015 supplement tracks developments taking place under the Renewable Energy Independent Power Producer Procurement Programme, which has had four bidding rounds. It appears to remain a shining light on the...
Electricity 2015: A review of South Africa's electricity sector (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s Electricity 2015 report provides an overview of State-owned power utility Eskom and independent power producers, as well as electricity planning, transmission, distribution and the theft thereof, besides other issues.
Construction 2015: A review of South Africa’s construction sector (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s Construction 2015 Report examines South Africa’s construction industry over the past 12 months. The report provides insight into the business environment; the key participants in the sector; local construction demand; geographic diversification;...
Liquid Fuels 2014 - A review of South Africa's Liquid Fuels sector (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s Liquid Fuels 2014 Report examines these issues, focusing on the business environment, oil and gas exploration, the country’s feedstock supplies, the development of South Africa’s biofuels industry, fuel pricing, competition in the sector, the...
Water 2014: A review of South Africa's water sector (PDF Report)
Creamer Media’s Water 2014 report considers the aforementioned issues, not only in the South African context, but also in the African and global context, and examines the issues of water and sanitation, water quality and the demand for water, among others.
This Week's Magazine
While strongly welcoming the promulgation of the new Part 101 of South Africa’s civil aviation regulations, governing the commercial operation of civil remotely piloted aircraft (RPAs) in South Africa, the Commercial Unmanned Aircraft Association of Southern Africa...
LSM Distributors has contracted engineering consultancy WSP | Parsons Brinckerhoff Africa to undertake the R100-million restoration of the 54-year-old Kyalami racetrack, situated in Midrand. The restoration will assist in re-establishing it as a venue for...
South African Defence Minister Nosiviwe Mapisa-Nqakula has expressed the hope that the defence budget will be significantly increased over the next five years. She did so while addressing the media in her recent budget vote media briefing. The 2015/2016 defence...
The African Development Bank (AfDB) has been an implementing agency for the Global Environment Facility (GEF) since 2008. The relatively young portfolio has 28 projects over 30 countries on the continent according to the 2014 AfDB and GEF annual report released...
Investment in South African youth through apprenticeships and learnerships will not only create direct benefits for businesses but will also contribute significantly to job creation and socioeconomic transformation in the country.